“We mentioned the F-35 subject. We made funds of $1.3 to $1.4 billion for the jets, and we noticed that Mr. Trump was well-intentioned about delivering them,” Erdogan mentioned. Notably, he added that Turkey’s Russian-made S-400 air protection system—on the heart of the years-long deadlock—“didn’t come up” in the course of the talks.
That element issues. In 2019, the US formally expelled Turkey from the multinational F-35 Joint Strike Fighter program, citing the S-400 buy as a direct risk to the plane’s stealth and intelligence safeguards. On the time, the choice was extensively seen as a pointy rebuke to a NATO ally drifting nearer to Moscow.
With a shifting geopolitical panorama and renewed U.S.-Turkey dialogue, the query returns: ought to Turkey be allowed again into the F-35 program?
Many nationwide safety consultants argue that the dangers of reintegration far outweigh the advantages—each technically and strategically.
“Turkey made its selection regardless of repeated warnings, recommendation, and stress from allies. It went into this with eyes extensive open and determined in 2019 to proceed with the S-400 missile protection system,” Sinan Ciddi, Affiliate Professor of Safety Research on the Marine Corps College and Senior Fellow for the Basis for Protection of Democracies, tells The Cipher Temporary. “On condition that, there’s no actual upside to letting Turkey again into the F-35 program. The related risks are important.”
Others contend that the potential upsides are price contemplating.
“Bringing Turkey again into the F-35 program may strengthen NATO’s southern flank, the place Turkey’s strategic place bordering Syria, Iran, and Russia issues. Its air pressure, caught with getting old F-16s, would acquire fifth-generation stealth with the F-35, boosting NATO interoperability and deterrence towards adversaries like China and Russia,” John Thomas, Managing Director of strategic advocacy agency, Nestpoint Associates, tells The Cipher Temporary. “The deal may enable Turkish companies to make elements which may decrease prices, saving US taxpayers billions.”
Ankara had invested roughly $1.4 billion into the undertaking earlier than its removing. Turkish protection contractors performed a key function in manufacturing over 900 elements for the plane, lots of which needed to be relocated to U.S. and European amenities at appreciable price and logistical pressure.
But even amongst advocates, most agree that reentry would have to be conditional and tightly managed.
There’s additionally a compelling strategic case. Geographically, Turkey straddles Europe, Asia, and the Center East, providing air base entry close to battle zones from Syria to the Caucasus and japanese Mediterranean.
Past {hardware} and geography, some view Turkey’s reintegration as a method to attract Ankara again from its more and more impartial protection path and nearer to the West. Erdogan has hedged towards U.S. sanctions by ramping up cooperation with Russia and accelerating growth of a homegrown fifth-generation fighter, the KAAN, which accomplished its first take a look at flight in early 2024.
The Cipher Temporary Risk Convention is going on October 19-22 in Sea Island, GA. The world’s main minds on nationwide safety from each the private and non-private sectors will probably be there. Are you able to afford to overlook out? Apply in your seat on the desk at present.
The Dangers That Haven’t Gone Away
Nonetheless, the issues that led to Turkey’s authentic expulsion stay unresolved. Chief amongst them is the continued presence of the Russian S-400 system on Turkish soil.
“The S-400’s radars are a dealbreaker,” Thomas asserted. “Russian methods may accumulate knowledge on the F-35’s stealth, risking leaks to Moscow, endangering American pilots and allies like Israel.”
Washington officers have repeatedly warned that working each the S-400 and F-35s in the identical setting poses an unacceptable threat to delicate knowledge and stealth expertise.
“To revive belief, Turkey should absolutely decommission its S-400s—dismantling key elements or transferring them to U.S. management at Incirlik. Authorized ensures, like a binding dedication to not procure Russian methods once more, have to be non-negotiable,” Thomas continued.
Whereas technical safeguards and authorized commitments might assist mitigate safety dangers, others warning that deeper strategic questions stay unresolved.
Jennifer Kavanagh, senior fellow and director of navy evaluation at Protection Priorities, tells The Cipher Temporary that there are a number of questions Washington officers must ask.
“How seemingly is it that Turkey would combat alongside the U.S. in a battle or disaster with F-35s ought to they regain entry to this system? Previously, they’ve even denied the U.S. even the flexibility to function from Turkish bases, so there are causes to be skeptical,” she mentioned.
From her purview, Ankara ought to “give the S-400 system again to Russia if they’re severe about reentering the F-35 program.”
“That is most likely not possible. Decommissioning the system is likely to be ample, however in that case, Turkey’s entry to the F-35’s labeled expertise needs to be restricted,” Kavanagh mentioned.
Though Turkish officers have hinted at a potential deactivation or sale of the S-400, no concrete steps have been taken.
Join the Cyber Initiatives Group Sunday publication, delivering expert-level insights on the cyber and tech tales of the day – on to your inbox. Join the CIG publication at present.
Congressional Crimson Traces and Govt Authority
Reintegrating Turkey wouldn’t simply be a navy or diplomatic determination—it might require navigating deep skepticism on Capitol Hill. Below the Countering America’s Adversaries By means of Sanctions Act (CAATSA), the U.S. imposed sanctions on Turkey’s protection procurement company in 2020. Lifting these sanctions would seemingly require congressional approval, and opposition stays robust.
Senator Jim Risch, a senior Republican on the Senate Overseas Relations Committee, has repeatedly acknowledged that Turkey shouldn’t obtain the F-35 so long as the S-400 is operational.
Furthermore, in July, a bipartisan letter started circulating within the Home, authored by Representatives Chris Pappas (D-NH), Gus Bilirakis (R-FL), Nicole Malliotakis (R-NY), and Dina Titus (D-NV). The lawmakers urged the administration to dam any efforts they are saying would violate U.S. regulation and compromise nationwide safety coverage. The State Division responded to the letter, saying: “We have now expressed our displeasure with Ankara’s acquisition of the S-400 system and have made clear the steps that needs to be taken as a part of our ongoing evaluation of the implementation of CAATSA sanctions.”
Ciddi identified, nonetheless, that there are methods to skirt Congress.
“The Nationwide Protection Authorization Act contains specific language: so long as Turkey maintains the S-400 on its soil, it can’t obtain the F-35. That’s been the case since 2019,” he defined. “May that be bypassed? If the President had been to invoke nationwide emergency powers, there’s a theoretical path round Congress.”
Past Congress, Ciddi continued, there are additionally “issues from U.S. allies—Israel, Greece, Cyprus—who argue Turkey has repeatedly crossed purple strains, not solely by buying Russian missile methods but additionally by deepening strategic ties with Moscow and supporting teams like Hamas.”
“It’s not simply concerning the S-400 anymore; it’s a few broader sample,” he mentioned. “Turkey isn’t simply shopping for arms from Russia. It’s additionally constructing nuclear energy crops with them, elevating issues about their eventual nuclear functionality. And nonetheless, Erdogan hasn’t been held to account.”
There are additionally regional implications to contemplate. Israel, which depends closely on its fleet of F-35s for sustaining its qualitative navy edge, has traditionally been cautious of superior U.S. weapons flowing to rivals or unstable actors within the area. Though Turkey and Israel have not too long ago taken cautious steps towards diplomatic normalization, tensions stay excessive over Ankara’s help for Hamas and its rhetoric towards Israeli navy operations.
On the identical time, Turkey’s protection posture has shifted notably since its removing. It has solid stronger ties with Russia, expanded protection commerce with Central Asian states, and emphasised sovereignty over strategic alignment. Erdogan’s authorities has leaned on nationalist rhetoric and positioned Turkey as an influence dealer, impartial of each the U.S. and the EU. Analysts underscore that re-admitting Ankara with out substantial ensures dangers validating this drift—and will erode the credibility of Western alliances.
A Conditional Path Again—If There Is One
But some analysts argue that the present geopolitical second provides a slender window for recalibration. The resurgence of great-power competitors, coupled with Turkey’s financial strains and regional fatigue, might make Erdogan extra inclined to interact in negotiations.
But, even restricted reentry carries important political and strategic dangers. Whether or not Turkey is introduced again in or saved at arm’s size, the choice will set a precedent not only for arms gross sales—however for a way the U.S. manages defiant allies in an period of world fragmentation.
Because the Protection Division emphasised in 2019, the F-35 program relies on mutual belief and alignment. The query now’s whether or not these foundations will be restored—or whether or not reengagement with out clear situations will do extra hurt than good.
“5 U.S. administrations now have all despatched the identical message: that Turkey is just too massive to fail. Irrespective of how Turkey undermines or acts towards U.S. pursuits, it has barely ever confronted any repercussions from Washington,” Blaise Misztal, Vice President for Coverage on the Jewish Institute for Nationwide Safety of America, tells The Cipher Temporary.
“To permit Turkey to get the F-35 now, with out actual steps to reveal it’s prepared to be a greater ally, will solely additional persuade Turkey that it may do no matter it needs with out worry of U.S. pushback. Nations surrounding Turkey, in the meantime, whether or not U.S. companions or not, will solely have their fears confirmed that they need to put together themselves to confront Turkey’s rising energy.”
Are you Subscribed to The Cipher Temporary’s Digital Channel on YouTube? There isn’t a higher place to get clear views from deeply skilled nationwide safety consultants.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Temporary as a result of Nationwide Safety is Everybody’s Enterprise.