Of their letter to the massive tech firms, the members of Congress known as undersea cables “one of the crucial strategically important, and more and more weak, elements of the world’s digital infrastructure…powering not solely international commerce and innovation but in addition the core operational techniques of nationwide safety, intelligence, and protection,” they usually warned that the cables may “turn out to be a backdoor for espionage, disruption, or exploitation of U.S. knowledge and communications belongings.”
Extra broadly, the undersea cable questions are the newest in a sequence of considerations about actions taken by Beijing to infiltrate American important infrastructure, following cyberattacks and breaches of U.S. water techniques, energy grids and different networks.
“The Chinese language have been grabbing huge knowledge from all types of communication that traverse the earth, together with a considerable quantity of U.S. and allied knowledge,” Rear Admiral (Ret.) Mike Studeman, a former Commander of the Workplace of Naval Intelligence, informed The Cipher Transient. “This isn’t some form of theoretical menace. That is attempting to cease one thing that is underway.”
The potential infiltration of the undersea cable community is “a major menace,” Nick Thompson, a former CIA paramilitary officer and Naval Particular Warfare Improvement Group operator, informed The Cipher Transient. “China has invested closely in cable restore infrastructure, and mixed with its fixed nefarious maritime exercise all through the world, it’s logical to raise the dangers to the very best ranges of [the U.S.] authorities.”
Sabotage and espionage on the ocean flooring
As The Cipher Transient has reported, undersea cables have turn out to be an unlimited and largely unseen piece of important international infrastructure. Roughly 650 cables cowl greater than 800,000 miles of ocean flooring, carrying a staggering 98 p.c of the world’s knowledge – every thing from e-mail site visitors to army communications to an estimated $22 trillion in monetary transactions processed day-after-day.
“When you consider the capability of these cables, it is terabytes of data versus gigabytes of data by way of satellites,” Rear Adm. Studeman mentioned. “While you undergo satellites, it is like ingesting a glass of water by way of the quantity of information throughput. However undersea cables, it is like attempting to drink a big swimming pool price of information. And so the menace is important…individuals attempting to get into your communications, manipulate them, or outright disrupt them by way of severing and reducing.”
The U.N. estimates that between 150-200 incidents of undersea cable harm happen annually, and whereas most are accidents involving dredging operations, dragged anchors, or pure disasters, cables have additionally been focused by saboteurs, working in what one report known as the “grey zone of deniable assaults in need of struggle.”
Russia and China have been accused of deliberately severing cables, significantly within the Baltic Sea and the waters close to Taiwan. In one of the crucial widely-reported instances, Taiwan mentioned that two submarine cables resulting in its island of Matsu had been minimize in 2023, inflicting widespread web outages. Taiwan blamed two Chinese language vessels for the harm, and officers in Taipei mentioned that they had documented 27 incidents since 2018 of Chinese language vessels damaging undersea cables that served the island.
China and Russia have denied tampering with any undersea cables.
Join the Cyber Initiatives Group Sunday publication, delivering expert-level insights on the cyber and tech tales of the day – on to your inbox. Join the CIG publication at present.
The newest considerations are much less about reducing cables, and extra concerning the entities that manufacture and preserve the undersea community. Greater than 90 p.c of the world’s subsea cables are manufactured and put in by 4 non-public companies: the American SubCom, France’s Alcatel Submarine Networks, Japan’s Nippon Electrical Firm and China’s HMN Applied sciences. Based on a report by the Middle for Strategic and Worldwide Research (CSIS), HMN, previously referred to as Huawei Marine Networks Co., Ltd., has been the world’s fastest-growing subsea cable builder over the previous decade, and accounts for 18 % of the cables at the moment on the ocean flooring.
HMN and the State-controlled Chinese language agency S.B. Submarine Programs (SBSS) are additionally main gamers within the cable restore area – they usually routinely underbid different firms for the restore work. Based on CSIS, HMN Applied sciences’ bids for undersea cable tasks are priced 20 to 30 p.c decrease than its rivals.
“If we depend on China for repairs, then one thing might be inserted in that course of to faucet that specific cable,” Beth Sanner, a former Deputy Director for Nationwide Intelligence on the ODNI, informed The Cipher Transient. “Anytime a Chinese language ship restore operation is occurring…all of those firms report again to Beijing. So I take into account that a fully excessive danger.”
Thompson famous that China affords an unparalleled suite of upkeep and restore companies for the subsea cable networks – they’ve “accessible belongings, they’ve the technical ability, and their companies are less expensive than Western firms,” he mentioned. And the CSIS report warned of frequent repairs carried out by “high-risk distributors, a few of whom are Chinese language.” It discovered that “the overreliance on Chinese language restore ships because of restricted alternate options within the market is one other vulnerability…There are considerations that Chinese language cable restore firms similar to SBSS may faucet undersea knowledge streams.”
Erin Murphy, a Deputy Director at CSIS and professional on the undersea cable problem, likened the cable-repair problem to the questions any shopper would possibly face when on the lookout for a fast and efficient repair.
“When you may have a cable that must be repaired, you mainly get in a queue to get a cable restore ship,” she informed The Cipher Transient. “And typically it is Chinese language. This does not imply that every one Chinese language ships are prepared for espionage and prepared for harm, however when there’s a have to restore cables, you’ve bought to go together with the first-come, first-serve.”
Rear Adm. Studeman made the excellence between “outside-in” sabotage – the cable-cutting incidents – and “inside-out operations” that is perhaps carried out in upkeep or restore work.
“The within-out menace is simply as important and we have to be aware of it,” Studeman mentioned. Entry to the cables, he mentioned, permits U.S. adversaries to both seize knowledge or sabotage the cables themselves.
“A part of it’s about espionage and the flexibility to shunt info into a spot the place Chinese language and Russian intelligence can undergo it,” he mentioned. “Even when it is encrypted, they’re hoping that in a while with decryption capabilities they’re engaged on that they might find yourself having all this knowledge that they will decrypt, and study all kinds of secrets and techniques.”
Everybody wants a very good nightcap. Ours occurs to come back within the type of a M-F publication that retains you on top of things on nationwide safety. Enroll at present.
What to do about the issue?
The latest congressional requests of the 4 tech juggernauts are primarily a probe of their publicity to undersea espionage. The letters went to these 4 firms for a very good motive: Amazon, Google, Meta, and Microsoft personal or lease roughly half of all undersea bandwidth.
The committees requested the businesses to submit detailed info on the subsea cable techniques they use – the businesses that manufacture and preserve them, and whether or not any China-linked “system components” are used within the cables. The tech companies had been additionally requested to offer lists of entities that had been contracted to work on the cables since Jan 1, 2018, details about how they monitor the site visitors of foreign-flagged vessels close to the cables, and “the bodily and cyber safeguards put in place by every firm to guard the cables throughout this upkeep or restore.”
The letters referenced Russia as nicely, however the focus was on China. The committees requested solutions by August 4, and a briefing from every firm by August 8, 2025.
After the deadlines handed, a supply near the committees would say solely that the tech companies had responded and that “now we have conferences arrange” on the problem. The Cipher Transient reached out to Meta, Microsoft, Google and Amazon for remark however now we have not heard again from them.
Regardless of the firms report, consultants are satisfied of the dangers, and lots of have supplied potential options. One apparent treatment would contain turning to American firms to do the upkeep and restore work. Specialists have known as for progress within the Cable Safety Fleet program, by way of which Congress has funded two privately-owned U.S. ships to restore lots of of cables that attain the U.S.
Amongst different concepts: Construct extra cables. As CSIS’s Murphy mentioned, “It comes right down to a redundancy problem. The extra cables that you simply lay…the extra redundancy you construct in.” Others have instructed establishing “a cable hall,” during which important cables are concentrated, which means business vessels know to keep away from the world, and monitoring is comparatively simple. The disadvantage is {that a} malign actor would presumably study concerning the location of “hall” as nicely.
Rear Adm. Studeman and others have instructed the usage of expertise to improve the cable community, making certain that extra undersea cables are “sensible,” and geared up with sonar to detect breaks simply. He instructed that sensors be positioned in cables that will detect anomalies and “point out that someone’s as much as no good.” Such anomalies would possibly embody sign distortions, latency delays, and any hints that restore work had been carried out in a questionable method.
“All these issues need to have extra sensors and subsequently extra evaluation and extra consciousness,” Studeman mentioned, “as a result of then you’ll know learn how to act appropriately to nip one thing within the bud, or to cease it quickly after you detect it.”
Finally, the considerations about infiltrating undersea cables quantity to at least one extra fear for nationwide safety officers who’re already involved that China has breached a spread of important techniques within the U.S.
“We all know that China’s inside our important infrastructure in the US,” Sanner mentioned. “And they’re there to pre-position themselves in case of struggle, or possibly at the same time as a preemptive factor to stop us from interfering in, for instance, a Taiwan invasion. So I might suppose that undersea cables are not any completely different in terms of the US.”
Are you Subscribed to The Cipher Transient’s Digital Channel on YouTube? There isn’t a higher place to get clear views from deeply skilled nationwide safety consultants.
Learn extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Transient as a result of Nationwide Safety is Everybody’s Enterprise.