The rivalry between “Household Man” and “The Simpsons” is probably not all that culturally related now, however at one time it was a reasonably tense affair. As “South Park” identified with its “Simpsons Already Did It” episode means again in 2002, Matt Groening’s seminal animated sequence is inescapably influential and irrespective of how exhausting a brand new grownup animated sequence tries, it’ll in the end find yourself utilizing a storyline that hews intently to a “Simpsons” episode. Even actual life can not help however be influenced by the present, with “The Simpsons” predicting dozens of real-life occasions and cultural developments earlier than they even occurred.
However with its deal with a boorish father determine as the top of a dysfunctional household, “Household Man” at all times appeared just a little extra indebted to “The Simpsons” than different exhibits. This in and of itself was the reason for the 2 exhibits’ notorious rivalry, which began after the “Simpsons” episode “Treehouse of Horror XXIII,” wherein a gaggle of Homer clones featured Peter Griffin himself. “Household Man” had a surprisingly bleak response to this within the 2007 episode “Movin’ Out (Brian’s Music),” wherein Quagmire forces himself on Marge earlier than gunning down the entire Simpsons household. Maybe unsurprisingly, Fox ensured this “joke” was minimize from the episode, however the “Simpsons”https://www.slashfilm.com/”Household Man” feud had been nicely and really ignited.
Throughout these intense early-aughts years, “The Simpsons” was by no means compelled to chop any makes an attempt to poke enjoyable at “Household Man” — largely as a result of the present prevented horrific sexual assault “gags.” Nonetheless, the writers did take it upon themselves to self-edit, reducing a sure kind of joke that had come to outline the humor on Seth MacFarlane’s present.
The Simpsons minimize the cutaways due to Household Man
Within the years because the “Simpsons”https://www.slashfilm.com/”Household Man” rivalry started, there was a cooling of tensions, with the 2 exhibits ultimately crossing over for a full episode in 2014, earlier than crossing over as soon as once more, this time together with “Bob’s Burgers,” in 2023. What do longtime “Simpsons” writers actually take into consideration “Household Man” now? Effectively, plenty of them have since labored on each exhibits, so there is definitely nothing just like the ire that existed between the 2 sequence again within the day.
Nonetheless, for followers of both present, it is enjoyable to delve into the historical past of this monumental TV beef. Notably attention-grabbing is the way in which wherein “The Simpsons” writers did greater than take jabs at “Household Man.” As revealed within the DVD commentary for the season 3 episode “Brother, Can You Spare Two Dimes?,” “Simpsons” writers deliberately stopped writing cutaway gags after “Household Man” ran that individual kind of joke into the bottom.
Within the episode, Mr. Burns is knowledgeable that Homer’s well being examination has revealed his sperm to be sterile. As a technique to appease his worker, Burns makes up a pretend award, “The First Annual Montgomery Burns Award for Excellent Achievement within the Subject of Excellence,” which comes with a money prize of $2,000. When the household debates what to do with the cash, Marge suggests shopping for a brand new washer and dryer set, earlier than the episode cuts to a shot of the basement the place the household cat, Snowball II, virtually will get flattened by the runaway home equipment.
Within the commentary monitor, producer and season 3 showrunner Al Jean reacted to this cutaway joke, saying:
“We had began doing these jokes much more at this level, the place we might minimize away to some unrelated visible. We did it lots for a pair years, then we did it much less, then ‘Household Man’ began doing it, after which we actually did not wish to do it anymore.”
In response, Govt Producer James L. Brooks says, “After which we knew it was useless,” with Jean responding, “As soon as they had been copying us.”
Seth MacFarlane bought his cutaways from The Simpsons
Although the present moved away from utilizing cutaway jokes because it went on, these fast gags truly made for a number of the finest moments on “The Simpsons.” Absolutely each fan remembers Homer’s “Land of Chocolate” daydream? The present was filled with this type of humor throughout its early years. Hans Moleman’s orange-eating class (“Simply eat the rattling oranges!”), or Homer’s imaginative and prescient of beginning a brand new life beneath the ocean, throughout which he eats all of the “pleasant crustaceans” he can. These are a number of the funniest moments within the present’s historical past, and it appears they really immediately impressed “Household Man” creator Seth MacFarlane.
Throughout a SXSW interview (through Forbes) MacFarlane admitted that “The Simpsons” was immediately liable for his present’s frequent use of cutaways, even citing Homer’s “Land of Chocolate” fantasy for example. “There have been issues like that they used sporadically,” he stated. “You recall every a type of so nicely that it appeared prefer it was a stylistic factor as a result of they had been so memorable.” In MacFarlane’s view, nonetheless, “The Simpsons” used cutaways “in restricted kind,” and the “Household Man” creator truly went into his present interested by the right way to use such gags “structurally.”
Certainly, “Household Man” turned this explicit type of humor into an artwork kind, to the extent now you can discover compilations of the present’s finest cutaways from any given season, and lists of the highest 10 cutaway jokes in “Household Man” historical past. However as time went on, this comedic type truly turned a purpose why many disliked the present.
Household Man’s cutaway jokes turned a joke
Through the years, “Household Man” began to take some warmth for its reliance on cutaway jokes, with “South Park” famously lampooning the present’s writing workers, depicting them as a tank filled with manatees who decide up “concept balls” and drop them in a joke generator to create what Cartman calls “one random interchangeable joke after one other.” MacFarlane addressed this type of hate throughout his SXSW look:
“It is one thing that in later years has virtually grow to be one thing that is s**t upon in writers circles. And it is attention-grabbing as a result of these are the toughest issues to write down. If you’re coping with story-based comedy it is virtually simpler. With the cutaways, it is advisable to develop a model new premise, storyline, arc, all in just some seconds.”
As “The Simpsons” has light into irrelevance and “South Park” has grow to be a form of cultural Rorschach take a look at, it is attention-grabbing to consider “Household Man” and its place in tradition. The present has come beneath plenty of hearth, partially attributable to its reliance on non-sequiturs, flashbacks, and cutaways. However “Household Man” has some undeniably traditional episodes that clearly had a serious cultural affect. Whereas MacFarlane has spoken overtly about being influenced by “The Simpsons,” the present additionally had its personal distinctive humorousness that went past simply cutaway gags.
As “Simpsons” author and co-showrunner for season 3, Mike Reiss, wrote in his e book “Springfield Confidential,” “When ‘Household Man’ debuted 10 years into ‘The Simpsons’ run, our youthful writers had been incensed: ‘It is simply vulgar!’ ‘It strikes too quick!’ ‘It is nothing however popular culture references!'” If something, then, whilst you can accuse “Household Man” of merely being a “Simpsons” rip-off, clearly the “Simpsons” writers themselves felt it was a a lot completely different present to their very own, which they’d presumably by no means say was “vulgar” or “nothing however popular culture references.”